By far, the plot of the book is one of the most interesting in the entire series. I liked how everything tied up in the end too, where segments of the action closed in to give readers that "oh!" moment. Jack and Annie are lured into a trap, set by the Ice wizard, the antagonist of the story, who tricks Morgan and Merlin. They must work together to assist him, by recovering his lost eye. Along the way, ups and downs keep the story-line flowing quite nicely. Definitely recommend!
- @Siri of The Hamilton Public Library's Teen Review Board

Weird story!! My daughter didn't feel good after reading this book. So far out of 25 magic tree house books she has read, it was the first one she didn't like. She is glad she borrowed it and not bought it.

i know right, AwakdawakTNY!

Awesome!!!

i've never seen somebody put their eye back into thir head!

i really love it all their journes were awsome this was one of the best books iv ever read i hope youl read it if you do youl get over exited all over the book thank you

I think it is great. His eye he traded and the sisters of fate weave peoples stories and how Annie gives them her scarf and they find it on their porch with their story on it!
Wonderful story!!

they alwas have epic journies

This book rules

jack and annie have to find an eye?!